On Sept. 10, officers with the Huntsville Police Department pulled over a car for failing to signal while changing lanes. Unbeknownst to the pair inside the car, agents with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms had been tailing the two men since they left nearby Decatur, Alabama.
As the officers approached the vehicle, they reportedly noticed that the two men were wearing body armor and armed with rifles and two 3D-printed pistols. According to a search warrant later filed in the Northern District of Alabama, the Huntsville officers ordered the two men to exit the car and conducted a probable cause search, uncovering dozens of rifle and pistol magazines with inscriptions on them.
One bullet magazine reportedly stated, “I hate the police.” Another had written on it, “Are we free yet?”
But what likely gave the officers real cause for concern was a notebook that allegedly had written on a page in all caps, “This is not a petty crime. This was an act of liberation. An act of resistance.”
The pair—18-year-old Levi “Cici” Belcher and 28-year-old Anthony “Violet” Slota—were arrested. The local officers then obtained a state warrant to search their Huntsville residence.
When the officers arrived, Belcher and Slota’s other roommate, 38-year-old Tadashi Erekson, reportedly answered the door. Officers then took Erekson into custody, too, after he allegedly reached for a concealed pistol holstered on his ankle.
In the house, the authorities later stated that they found dozens of 3D-printed pistol frames, anti-government writings scribbled onto the walls and on leaflets, and 3D-printed grenade housings.
The investigators also allegedly recovered a short-barreled shotgun, which Congress had criminalized the making or transferring of without registering with the Attorney General through the National Firearms Act in 1934. Investigators wrote the sawed-off shotgun had not been registered.
This gave the Justice Department an opening to take the case federal. A day later, Sept. 11, the ATF filed criminal complaints against all three roommates for allegedly possessing an unregistered short-barreled shotgun.
Philip Williams, the U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Alabama, said in a Justice Department press release issued on Oct. 8 after the trio was indicted: “My office will take every available step to prosecute credible threats against law enforcement.”
But, less than a month later, prosecutors dropped the gun charge against all three defendants without their defense attorneys entering so much as a written motion.
How’d the purported left-wing extremists get so lucky? Their arrests coincided with a conservative legal movement to expand the scope of the Second Amendment and a ruling holding key parts of the National Firearms Act unconstitutional, upending prosecutions across the country.
The Rest of This Story Is Behind a Paywall
Let's explain why. Our Friday morning roundups are always free. However, this story is part of our weekly Sunday Series we call The Rabbit Hole where we choose a single federal court docket, filing, or topic and dive deep into the details. To do the stories in the series properly, we invest significant reporting resources that can only happen with subscriber support.
Upgrade To Read the Rest
