The University of Central Florida football team knocked off No. 10 Brigham Young University in a double overtime upset — one of the bright moments in an up-and-down football season this year.
But missing from the sidelines was the longtime head UCF football trainer Mary Vander Heiden. A new federal lawsuit explains her absence. She claims she was fired after reporting sexual harassment in the athletics department.
“In February 2024, Ms. Vander Heiden reported that two male coaches had sexually harassed a female collegiate-athlete and that nothing was being done about it,” her lawsuit said. “Her supervisor admonished her for being involved, told her to stay out of it, and fired her eleven weeks later.”
The federal lawsuit also highlights the lack of transparency at university athletic departments. The UCF Athletics Association is exempt from the same public record laws governing the university, making it difficult to find out more about the football trainer’s termination.
Vander Heiden sued UCF Trustees and the UCF Athletics Association Nov. 10 in the Middle District of Florida’s Orlando division.
UCF may not be the name you recognize instantly if you’re not from Florida. However, the school in Orlando known as Knights is actually the largest school in the state and among the biggest in the country with more than 70,000 students.
That’s where Vander Heiden worked for 25 years where she worked as the head football trainer since 2007, her federal lawsuit said.
Her career included accolades, like when she was named the Dr. Robert Cade Sports Medicine Person of the Year by the Athletic Trainers Association of Florida in 2022.
Her job as UCF Associate Director for Sports Medicine and head football athletic trainer carried big responsibilities and she was paid $103,600 a year, according to her lawsuit.
“Plaintiff was responsible for hiring, supervision, budgeting, and compliance for a Sports Medicine Team of 17 athletic trainers serving every intercollegiate sport,” her lawsuit said.
Vander Heiden, a Washington native, was a former college athlete herself. She played softball, her bio said.
Vander Heiden’s lawsuit details the end of her career. Or at least her version of events.
“On February 27, 2024, Head Softball Coach Cindy Ball-Malone told Plaintiff that a female softball collegiate-athlete had complained about two male coaches,” her lawsuit said. “An assistant softball coach had hit on the athlete and told her he loved her. A male strength coach had sent the athlete direct messages, which Coach Ball-Malone saw.”
Vander Heiden and the softball coach took action, the lawsuit said.
“Plaintiff went with Coach Ball-Malone to report the incidents to Deputy Athletics Director Chris McFarlane,” the lawsuit said. “That same day, Plaintiff reported the harassing behavior to Defendant UCF on Defendant UCF's Title IX reporting form.”
Vander Heiden wasn’t happy with how the university was handling the situation. “Plaintiff then complained that nothing was being done about the male coaches' conduct toward the athlete,” the federal lawsuit said.
Abigail Wilson, the Deputy Athletics Director who was also the UCF's Deputy Title IX Coordinator of Athletics, “admonished Plaintiff for ‘being involved,’” the lawsuit said.
On May 13, 2024, Vander Heiden said she was called into a meeting that she thought was about basketball trainer candidates. Instead, Wilson fired her, the lawsuit said.
“Before the termination, Plaintiff had not received any discipline, counseling memorandum, or negative evaluation. No reason was given for Plaintiff’s termination at the time of termination,” the federal lawsuit said. “After firing Plaintiff, Defendants hired a man to work as Head Football Athletic Trainer.”
Vander Heiden said her replacement as Head Football Athletic Trainer “earned more than Plaintiff had earned for performing both that role and the position of Associate Athletic Director,” the lawsuit said.
Now, she is suing for unpaid wages and back pay, attorneys' fees and more.
Court Watch requested records about Vander Heiden’s firing or the sexual harassment allegations.
UCF declined to release records about Vander Heiden’s departure because its athletics association is classified as a “direct support organization” in Florida law. That means it is a “not-for-profit corporation” even though it is located at a public university.
Direct support organizations are “not subject to the same open records laws as the university or other public institutions,” wrote Adam Widman, Senior Associate Athletic Director for UCF Athletics, in an email.
So UCF, which often releases employee personnel files, emails and investigations to public records requests, is allowed to keep information on Vander Heiden’s termination confidential.
WUFT, a public media station, reported university athletic associations have been able to keep information secret, like how much the University of Florida spent on hotels, meals and transportation for the football team.
“This protection is said to ensure the privacy of the organizations, but some call it an overbroad restriction that gives more power to the already powerful university system,” the story said.
Court Watch was also unable to confirm more information about the softball player who accused two coaches of harassing her.
Widman cited Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) to explain why any records were confidential.
“Given the targeted nature of your request, it is impossible for the University to respond without revealing non-directory information. As such, there are no documents which are responsive to your request which are not otherwise confidential and exempt,” he wrote.
UCF officials declined to comment further or to respond to the lawsuit’s allegations for this this story
Vander Heiden’s lawyers did not respond to a request for comment. Court Watch also asked them to provide any records that prove their claims in the lawsuit, but again, they did not respond.
